openclaw - 💡(How to fix) Fix Android node: support `location.enabledMode: always` (background location via foreground service) [1 participants]

Summary

On the Android node app, nodes location get currently only works when the OpenClaw app is in the foreground. Any background call fails with LOCATION_BACKGROUND_UNAVAILABLE. The Location Command docs already spec location.enabledMode: always and describe the intended Android behavior under a "Background behavior (future)" heading, but the Android app only exposes Off / While Using in Settings today.

This issue is a request to ship that future behavior: let users opt into Always mode on Android, backed by a foreground service, so an agent can fetch location on a schedule (cron, heartbeat, activity tracker, etc.) without having to keep the app visible.

Motivation / real use case

I'm running a 30-minute activity-tracker cron on my Gateway that logs where I am + what I'm doing. Today:

• macOS node → openclaw nodes location get --node "Jeremie's MacBook Air" returns GPS fine. ✅
• Android node (Pixel, paired, app installed, location permission granted while using) → fails with LOCATION_BACKGROUND_UNAVAILABLE unless I manually foreground the app. ❌

So when I'm out of the house with only my phone, the tracker falls back to heuristics (agenda, last known location) instead of real GPS. Across a user base this is a common pattern — any scheduled agent that wants mobile location will hit this.

Current state (as of 2026.4.15)

CLI side (works):

openclaw nodes location get --node <nodeId> --json

Returns a clean payload with lat, lon, accuracyMeters, isPrecise, timestamp. Error codes are already stable (LOCATION_DISABLED, LOCATION_PERMISSION_REQUIRED, LOCATION_BACKGROUND_UNAVAILABLE, LOCATION_TIMEOUT, LOCATION_UNAVAILABLE).

Android app side (partial):

• Settings selector: Off / While Using only (no Always).
• Single toggle: Precise Location.
• Behavior: any location.get while backgrounded returns LOCATION_BACKGROUND_UNAVAILABLE.
• Docs already note: "Android app currently supports foreground location only."

Proposed change

Ship the "Background behavior (future)" section from the current spec:

1. Add Always to the Android Settings selector, with the same tri-state UX already documented for iOS/macOS: Off / While Using / Always.
2. Request ACCESS_BACKGROUND_LOCATION when user picks Always. Android 11+ sends the user into system Settings for that grant — follow that flow and gracefully revert to whileUsing if denied, as the spec prescribes ("If OS denies requested level, revert to the highest granted level and show status").
3. Run a foreground service when Always is active, declared with foregroundServiceType="location" (required on Android 14+). Show a small persistent notification while the service is active — Android requires visibility anyway.
4. On a location.get invoke while backgrounded, if mode is always + grant is present → start a short-lived location request via that service, return the fix, stop. No need for continuous tracking: episodic wake-and-fix is enough for the scheduled-cron use case.
5. Error matrix stays the same — just stop emitting LOCATION_BACKGROUND_UNAVAILABLE when mode is always and background grant is present. (Keep the code, because it still applies when mode is whileUsing + backgrounded.)

Manifest bits (sketch)

If the app doesn't already declare them (can't easily check from outside):

<uses-permission android:name="android.permission.ACCESS_BACKGROUND_LOCATION" />
<uses-permission android:name="android.permission.FOREGROUND_SERVICE" />
<uses-permission android:name="android.permission.FOREGROUND_SERVICE_LOCATION" />
<!-- Needed only if targeting Android 14+ -->

<service
    android:name=".location.LocationForegroundService"
    android:foregroundServiceType="location"
    android:exported="false" />

Where this likely lives in the codebase

Based on the OpenClaw-Book TOC, the Android node app is under:

• apps/android/ (Kotlin) in the openclaw/openclaw monorepo, or a sibling repo if split.
• Section 28.3 of the book: "Android Node App — Kotlin architecture / Canvas / Camera / Screen recording".

Files worth touching (names inferred from Android conventions + existing capabilities):

• AndroidManifest.xml → permissions + service declaration above.
• The Kotlin module that handles the location.get RPC from the Gateway (look for the string LOCATION_BACKGROUND_UNAVAILABLE — there should be exactly one emitter).
• The Settings screen where location.enabledMode is stored (currently off | whileUsing).
• Add a new LocationForegroundService class handling start/stop + single-shot fix via FusedLocationProviderClient.getCurrentLocation(...).

If the LOCATION_BACKGROUND_UNAVAILABLE emitter is a single when branch gating on isAppForeground, the real fix is probably small: replace that branch with "if mode is always and we have background permission, start the foreground service and fulfill the request; otherwise emit the existing error."

Alternatives considered

• Push-triggered wake (the iOS pattern described in the spec): would work via FCM data messages, but Android 12+ heavily restricts background starts from data pushes. A foreground service with Always permission is the cleaner, user-visible path.
• Keeping the app foregrounded: works today, but defeats the point of scheduled agents on a phone.
• Relying on whileUsing + launching the app from ADB/automation: not a real-user solution.

Privacy / UX considerations

• Always must remain opt-in with an explicit OS-level prompt. The docs already propose the UX copy: "Allow background location. Requires system permission."
• The foreground service notification should state clearly that OpenClaw is accessing location in the background. This is a hard Android requirement and also the right thing.
• Precise vs coarse should stay orthogonal to the mode selector, as already specified.

Acceptance criteria

• Android Settings selector shows Off / While Using / Always.
• Selecting Always triggers the ACCESS_BACKGROUND_LOCATION flow.
• With Always granted, openclaw nodes location get --node <pixel> returns a valid fix while the app is backgrounded.
• With whileUsing granted and app backgrounded, LOCATION_BACKGROUND_UNAVAILABLE is still returned (existing behavior preserved).
• Foreground service notification appears while the service is active, and disappears after the fix returns.
• Docs page Location Command updated: remove the "(future)" marker from "Background behavior", document Android foreground service behavior.

Context

Tested on:

• OpenClaw 2026.4.15 (041266a), Linux Gateway on VPS.
• Android node: Pixel, app installed & paired, location.enabledMode = whileUsing, precise enabled.
• Command that triggers: openclaw nodes location get --node "Pixel de <name>" --json.

Happy to test a pre-release build against my setup if useful.