hermes - 💡(How to fix) Fix [Bug]: Discord VC TTS plays successfully (ffmpeg exit 0) but user hears nothing — no green speaking ring [1 participants]

Bug Description

When connected to a Discord voice channel, the TTS pipeline completes successfully — [Discord] Playing TTS in voice channel is logged, ffmpeg exits with code 0, and the audio file is valid (ElevenLabs confirms generation). However, the user hears nothing in the voice channel. The bot avatar shows no green speaking ring during playback, suggesting Discord is rejecting or not routing the audio stream.

This is already documented as Bug #3 in the discord-voice-troubleshooting skill.

Environment

• Hermes Agent: current upstream main as of 2026-04-27
• Platform: Discord gateway
• TTS Provider: ElevenLabs
• STT: faster-whisper (local)
• session_reset.mode: none
• OS: Ubuntu, host "Neuromancer"

Steps to Reproduce

1. Connect bot to a Discord voice channel (/voice channel or /voice join)
2. Speak to the bot in VC — STT transcribes successfully (confirmed in logs)
3. Bot generates text response → gateway auto-TTS triggers play_in_voice_channel()
4. Observe: ffmpeg runs and exits 0, but user hears nothing

Expected Behavior

TTS audio should be audible in the voice channel. Discord should show a green speaking ring around the bot avatar during playback.

Actual Behavior

• [Discord] Playing TTS in voice channel logged ✓
• ffmpeg process ... successfully terminated with return code of 0 logged ✓
• ElevenLabs confirms audio generation ✓
• User hears silence ✗
• No green speaking ring on bot avatar ✗

Log Evidence

2026-04-27 12:31:34,865 INFO gateway.platforms.discord: [Discord] Playing TTS in voice channel (guild=1487436095632441475)
2026-04-27 12:31:51,969 INFO discord.player: ffmpeg process 1273260 successfully terminated with return code of 0.

2026-04-27 12:36:40,324 INFO gateway.platforms.discord: [Discord] Playing TTS in voice channel (guild=1487436095632441475)
2026-04-27 12:36:43,688 INFO discord.player: ffmpeg process 1288621 successfully terminated with return code of 0.

Both instances produced silence for the user.

Suspected Areas

The pipeline from ffmpeg output → Discord voice socket appears to be the gap:

1. Discord SPEAKING opcode (op 5) — the bot may not be sending the SPEAKING indicator before streaming audio, causing Discord to ignore the stream
2. Channel-level SPEAK permission override — even with correct server invite permissions (274881432640), individual voice channels can override. But the green ring absence suggests Discord never receives the speaking signal, not a permission mute
3. Bot volume — Discord client sometimes defaults bot volume to 0. However, the lack of green ring points upstream of this

Related

• The discord-voice-troubleshooting skill documents this exact scenario as Known Bug #3
• The TTS Response Paths table in that skill documents the two code paths: gateway auto-TTS (plays in VC) vs agent TTS tool (sends as attachment). This bug is on the gateway auto-TTS path
• Issue #10163 may be related if gateway restarts are involved in the session context loss sometimes observed alongside this

Question

Is the SPEAKING opcode handshake properly implemented in the play_in_voice_channel path? The absence of the green ring strongly suggests Discord never receives the speaking indicator before/during the audio stream.