openclaw - 💡(How to fix) Fix Codex app-server idle watchdog fires after image_generation_call raw completed item [2 pull requests]

Summary

A Codex app-server turn can be retired by the idle watchdog after an image-generation item completes. This looks like the same liveness/watchdog class as #82274, but the last delivered raw item is image_generation_call rather than custom_tool_call_output.

User-facing symptom: the Telegram task appears to silently stop after image generation work. No final assistant response is delivered, and the session later ends as interrupted.

Environment

Observed timeline

A Telegram turn that was generating a batch of images got stuck in model_call after image generation progress had already been reported.

Sanitized log/signature:

long-running session ... activeWorkKind=model_call ... terminalProgressStale=true
lastProgress=codex_app_server:notification:rawResponseItem/completed
lastNotificationItemType=image_generation_call
codex app-server turn idle timed out waiting for completion
codex app-server client retired after timed-out turn

The session trajectory later ended with:

status=interrupted

The important part is that OpenClaw saw a rawResponseItem/completed notification for an item of type image_generation_call, but did not receive a terminal completion event for the turn. After the idle window, the app-server client was retired. From the user's perspective the task just stopped without the final answer.

Why this looks related to existing reports

This is very close to:

• #82274 / #82378: Codex app-server stalls mid-turn after a raw completed item, then the watchdog fires. That fix covers the custom_tool_call_output path.
• #78756 / #79667: broader progress-aware app-server timeout/liveness handling.

This repro differs in the last item type:

#82274: custom_tool_call_output
this case: image_generation_call

So this may be an adjacent edge case in the same watchdog/liveness logic, where completed image-generation items are not enough to guarantee the turn will either continue streaming or close cleanly.

Expected behavior

After a completed image_generation_call raw item, the Codex app-server/OpenClaw wrapper should either:

1. receive and process the normal terminal turn completion, or
2. continue treating meaningful image-generation progress as scoped turn activity until completion, or
3. fail the turn fast with a clear recoverable error instead of silently retiring the client after the idle watchdog.

It should not leave the user-facing Telegram task in a silent/ambiguous interrupted state.

Suggested investigation

Check whether the liveness/watchdog handling added around #82378 treats image_generation_call items differently from custom_tool_call_output, especially when the raw item is completed but no turn/completed event follows.

A useful regression would simulate:

rawResponseItem/completed, item.type=image_generation_call
(no terminal completion follows within idle window)

and assert that the wrapper reports a clear timeout/failure path, preserves diagnostics, and does not make the Telegram session look like a silent interruption.