openclaw - 💡(How to fix) Fix Feature: subcommand-level exec allowlisting [1 participants]

TL;DR

Implementing subcommand-level patterns in the allowlist, such as "openclaw:cron:list" or glob patterns like "openclaw cron *", is likely to provide the necessary granularity for security management.

Guidance

• Evaluate the proposed solution of supporting subcommand-level patterns in the allowlist to determine its feasibility and potential impact on the current system.
• Consider the use of glob patterns to simplify the allowlisting process for related subcommands, such as "openclaw cron *" to allow all cron subcommands.
• Assess the current workaround of using shell wrapper scripts and determine if it can be improved or replaced with a more efficient solution.
• Develop a clear understanding of the required security rules and how they can be implemented using the proposed subcommand-level allowlisting.

Example

A potential allowlist configuration could include patterns like:

openclaw:cron:list
openclaw:cron:run
openclaw:cron:edit
openclaw:status

Or using glob patterns:

openclaw cron *
openclaw:status

Notes

The implementation of subcommand-level patterns may require significant changes to the existing allowlist system, and careful consideration should be given to potential security implications and edge cases.

Recommendation

Apply the proposed workaround of using subcommand-level patterns in the allowlist, as it provides a more fine-grained control over allowed commands and can help improve the overall security posture of the system. This approach allows for more precise control over which subcommands are allowed, reducing the risk of unauthorized access or actions.