hermes - 💡(How to fix) Fix [Feature]: Suggestion List for Hermes Team [1 participants]

Problem or Use Case

Suggestion List for Hermes Team – Feature Requests & Improvements

• Built‑in suggestion window in the UI

  • A persistent, non‑intrusive modal or side panel where users can type and submit suggestions directly from the chat interface.
  • Includes fields for title, description, category (UI, performance, new feature, bug, documentation), and optional tags.

• User voting & commenting

  • Other users can upvote/downvote and comment on submitted suggestions to help prioritize community‑driven ideas.
  • Sorting options: most votes, newest, status (under review, planned, implemented).

• AI‑generated suggestion logging

  • The agent automatically detects recurring pain points, repeated questions, or workflow friction during conversations and logs them as candidate suggestions.
  • AI checks existing suggestions to avoid duplicates before creating a new entry.
  • Each AI‑generated suggestion includes a brief summary of the chat context (anonymized) and a confidence score.

• Deduplication & similarity detection

  • Background process that compares new submissions (user or AI) against existing ones using NLP similarity to prevent duplicate entries.
  • When a near‑duplicate is detected, the system prompts the user to upvote the existing item or clarify differences.

• Integration with issue tracker (e.g., GitHub)

  • Approved suggestions can be automatically turned into issues in the Hermes repository with labels like suggestion, enhancement, or feature-request.
  • Two‑way sync: issue status updates (open, in progress, closed) reflect back in the UI suggestion list.

• Notification & feedback loop

  • Users receive notifications when their suggestion changes status (e.g., “Under review”, “Planned for next release”, “Implemented”).
  • Option to follow specific suggestions for updates.

• Categorization & tagging system

  • Predefined categories: UI/UX, Performance, New Feature, Documentation, Security, Integration, Skill/Tool improvement.
  • Free‑form tags allow users to highlight specific areas (e.g., cronjob, obsidian, web-search).

• AI‑driven pattern analysis across sessions

  • Periodic analysis of aggregated, anonymized chat data to surface common improvement areas (e.g., “Users repeatedly ask how to X”).
  • AI drafts suggestion entries for the team to review, reducing manual effort.

• Public roadmap & status board

  • A read‑only view showing suggested features grouped by status: Backlog, In Progress, Testing, Released.
  • Users can see estimated timelines or release milestones for high‑voted items.

• Export & offline review

  • Ability to export the suggestion list (CSV/JSON) for archival or external discussion.
  • Import function allows communities to batch‑submit suggestions from offline meetings.

• Sandbox / preview environment

  • For UI or feature suggestions, provide a temporary preview mode where users can test a prototype before final approval (if feasible).

• Analytics dashboard for administrators

  • Metrics: number of suggestions submitted, average response time, top‑voted categories, AI‑generated suggestion rate, implementation rate.

• Documentation‑improvement triggers

  • When the AI notices users frequently asking about a particular topic that lacks clear docs, it logs a suggestion to enhance or create documentation for that topic.

• Skill/tool‑specific suggestion linking

  • Suggestions can be tied to existing Hermes skills (e.g., obsidian-chat-backup-system, trello-kimai-correlation-analysis) so maintainers know which area is affected.

Feel free to copy this list into a GitHub issue, discussion, or feature‑request template. Adjust wording or add any additional points that match your workflow.

Proposed Solution

its a list made with the suggestions

Alternatives Considered

No response

Feature Type

New tool

Scope

None

Contribution

• I'd like to implement this myself and submit a PR

Debug Report (optional)