openclaw - 💡(How to fix) Fix [Question/Roadmap] memory-wiki — Is there a plan for populating concepts/entities/syntheses folders? [1 participants]

Official PRs (…)
ON THIS PAGE

Recommended Tools

×6

Utilities matched from this issue’s tags and category — try them while you read without losing context.

GitHub issue graph ai analysis

Paste a GitHub issue URL. We fetch that issue, discover linked issues from bodies/comments/timeline, collect linked pull requests, and produce a structured English report.

The report is written in English Markdown for sharing and archival.

Helpful · Quick feedback

Loading…
GitHub stats
openclaw/openclaw#68598Fetched 2026-04-19 15:09:46
View on GitHub
Comments
0
Participants
1
Timeline
0
Reactions
0
Author
Participants

I'm using OpenClaw v2026.4.11 (upgrading to v2026.4.15 shows the same behavior) with the memory-wiki plugin in unsafe-local vault mode. The plugin scaffolds the following folder layout at my vault root:

OpenClaw/
├── sources/       (559 files, actively populated by nightly import)
├── reports/       (6 files: claim-health, contradictions, lint, low-confidence, open-questions, stale-pages)
├── concepts/      (only index.md with "No concepts yet")
├── entities/      (only index.md with "No entities yet")
├── syntheses/     (only index.md with "No syntheses yet")
├── _attachments/  (empty)
└── _views/        (empty)

`openclaw wiki status` confirms:

``` Pages: 559 sources, 0 entities, 0 concepts, 0 syntheses, 6 reports ```

`openclaw wiki doctor` reports `healthy`.

Root Cause

I'm using OpenClaw v2026.4.11 (upgrading to v2026.4.15 shows the same behavior) with the memory-wiki plugin in unsafe-local vault mode. The plugin scaffolds the following folder layout at my vault root:

OpenClaw/
├── sources/       (559 files, actively populated by nightly import)
├── reports/       (6 files: claim-health, contradictions, lint, low-confidence, open-questions, stale-pages)
├── concepts/      (only index.md with "No concepts yet")
├── entities/      (only index.md with "No entities yet")
├── syntheses/     (only index.md with "No syntheses yet")
├── _attachments/  (empty)
└── _views/        (empty)

`openclaw wiki status` confirms:

``` Pages: 559 sources, 0 entities, 0 concepts, 0 syntheses, 6 reports ```

`openclaw wiki doctor` reports `healthy`.

Code Example

OpenClaw/
├── sources/       (559 files, actively populated by nightly import)
├── reports/       (6 files: claim-health, contradictions, lint, low-confidence, open-questions, stale-pages)
├── concepts/      (only index.md with "No concepts yet")
├── entities/      (only index.md with "No entities yet")
├── syntheses/     (only index.md with "No syntheses yet")
├── _attachments/  (empty)
└── _views/        (empty)
RAW_BUFFERClick to expand / collapse

Context

I'm using OpenClaw v2026.4.11 (upgrading to v2026.4.15 shows the same behavior) with the memory-wiki plugin in unsafe-local vault mode. The plugin scaffolds the following folder layout at my vault root:

OpenClaw/
├── sources/       (559 files, actively populated by nightly import)
├── reports/       (6 files: claim-health, contradictions, lint, low-confidence, open-questions, stale-pages)
├── concepts/      (only index.md with "No concepts yet")
├── entities/      (only index.md with "No entities yet")
├── syntheses/     (only index.md with "No syntheses yet")
├── _attachments/  (empty)
└── _views/        (empty)

`openclaw wiki status` confirms:

``` Pages: 559 sources, 0 entities, 0 concepts, 0 syntheses, 6 reports ```

`openclaw wiki doctor` reports `healthy`.

What I've checked

  • `openclaw wiki --help` — no sub-command for `concepts` / `entities` / `syntheses` extraction or generation
  • Changelog for v2026.4.12 / v2026.4.14 / v2026.4.15 — no mention of these pipelines
  • Open PRs (#67329, #68041, #67208, #68586 and ~15 others) on the memory-wiki plugin — all bridge-import bug fixes, none adding extractors
  • Related roadmap issues:
    • #11946 (Post-Conversation Hook for Automated Knowledge Extraction) — open
    • #62703 (Post-turn capture hook with structured output routing) — open, not merged

Question

  1. Are the `concepts/` / `entities/` / `syntheses/` folders intended to be user-maintained editorial destinations (I fill them manually), or are they placeholders for a future auto-generation pipeline (extractor that walks `sources/` and writes these)?

  2. If the latter, is there a roadmap / target version for when these pipelines ship? Is it gated on the post-turn hook primitive (#62703) landing first?

  3. If there's no plan, would you accept a community-contributed extractor skill that populates these folders based on the current `sources/` corpus (using LLM extraction, written into the existing schema with `<!-- openclaw:wiki:... -->` markers)?

Just trying to understand whether I should (a) wait, (b) build my own, or (c) treat these as manual editorial folders.

Thanks for the great plugin btw — the `sources/` + `reports/` pipelines have been very useful.

extent analysis

TL;DR

The concepts/, entities/, and syntheses/ folders are likely intended as placeholders for a future auto-generation pipeline, but there is no clear roadmap or target version for their implementation.

Guidance

  • Review the OpenClaw documentation and changelogs to confirm the intended use of the concepts/, entities/, and syntheses/ folders.
  • Check the status of related roadmap issues, such as #11946 and #62703, to determine if there are any plans for auto-generation pipelines.
  • Consider contributing a community-developed extractor skill to populate these folders, using LLM extraction and the existing schema with <!-- openclaw:wiki:... --> markers.
  • Treat the concepts/, entities/, and syntheses/ folders as manual editorial destinations in the short term, until further guidance is available.

Notes

The issue lacks a clear statement on the intended use of the concepts/, entities/, and syntheses/ folders, and there is no explicit roadmap or target version for their implementation. The community may need to wait for further updates or consider contributing their own solutions.

Recommendation

Apply workaround: Treat the concepts/, entities/, and syntheses/ folders as manual editorial destinations for now, and consider contributing a community-developed extractor skill to populate these folders in the future. This approach allows users to utilize the existing sources/ and reports/ pipelines while waiting for further guidance on the auto-generation pipelines.

Vote matrix · Quick signals

Works
Did the solution work? Tap to confirm.
Easy Fix
Was it a quick fix?
Time Saver
Did it save you time?
Blocking
Was it severely blocking?
Common Issue
Are others likely hitting this too?
Flaky / Intermittent
Is it intermittent?
Verified / Reproducible
Can you reproduce it reliably?
Loading…

Still need to ship something?

×6

Another batch ranked right after the header list — different links, same matching logic.

Back to top recommendations

TRENDING

openclaw - 💡(How to fix) Fix [Question/Roadmap] memory-wiki — Is there a plan for populating concepts/entities/syntheses folders? [1 participants]